Moving Past the Guru: When Teachers Fail to Embody What They Teach
- Joanna Janke

- 2 days ago
- 3 min read
Updated: 2 days ago
How Do You Teach Meditation?
I've been asking myself this question before starting my certification, but my more important self-inquiry was: what do I want my students to carry away from our sessions together? I don't believe in the power of knowledge on its own - not because knowledge isn't valuable, but because meditation without experience is just philosophy. I believe in lived experience. If I hadn't experienced the process myself - the struggle, the deeper states, the effects - if I hadn't embodied the teachings, how could I be an authentic teacher?
It's crucial for me to be credible - to pass on knowledge that's been alive for thousands of years, not as empty words, but as something I've lived. The mystery hidden in the meditation tradition, dating back to the ancient rishis, fascinates me deeply. Imagine how many have already experienced what lies behind what we call reality. Through meditation, countless people have noticed the same depths, experienced something beyond the ordinary, and were able to pass that knowledge on. That's how the Vedas came to life, the Upanishads, the Gita. These aren't just texts - they're living transmissions of direct experience, passed from teacher to student across millennia. This is how lived experience became theory - the kind our distracted, overstimulated world so desperately needs.
The Bridge-Builders
Today we also have teachers. Those who adapted Eastern knowledge into modern language are often called New Age gurus - though "New Age" carries negative connotations, conjuring images of crystal shops and commercialised spirituality, wisdom repackaged for mass consumption. Whatever the label, these teachers serve an important purpose. Some are genuine, some opportunistic, but as bridge-builders they translated the Vedas, demystified meditation, and made yoga accessible to people who would never set foot in an ashram. They open doors that might otherwise remain closed.
These teachers play a crucial role in today's consumption-driven, dopamine-focused society. They distill the essence, making Eastern teachings accessible without requiring you to decode Sanskrit.
The unfortunate reality, however, is that many people blindly follow these, often valuable, paths, believing they contain all there is. The door a teacher opens, however, still needs to be walked through alone. If we stop where our teacher stops, our path becomes narrow. We risk losing touch with our own experience, hard-wired into someone else's journey. And when the guru inevitably fails, there is nothing left to stand on.
When the Mirror Cracks
The recent media revelations about a teacher I had looked up to taught me a valuable lesson and pushed me toward deeper personal growth. I experienced it as a finger pointing exactly to where my own limitations were. What followed was a clear internal voice: "You now go your own way."
This wake-up call was what I truly needed - a dose of humility and a renewed commitment to developing my own practice. It didn't come easily. I went through disbelief, then grief, and finally acceptance. What was actually hurting was my ego - the painful realization that the values I strive to embody were not being lived by someone I had admired.
Honor the Lineage, Refuse the Dependency
That realization clarified something important. If embodiment matters more than words, then my responsibility is to the practice itself - not to any particular teacher.
As a meditation instructor, I don't want to simply repeat what I've been taught. I want to enrich myself, arrive at my own conclusions, and share from that place. Teachers are messengers for whom I'm grateful - even those who turned out to have never embodied their own teachings. If I choose to embody them - and I do, though I'm still just a human with many flaws - that becomes my own quiet victory. Not that I wish to win anything, other than my own growth.
Whatever happens to your teacher, however disappointing, does not invalidate the teachings themselves when they come from an ancient tradition. Most importantly, their failings should not stop your own growth or become a new excuse for self-indulgence. Don't use your teacher's shortcomings to abandon the practice or lower your own standards.
This is what I say to myself - and what I wish for all of you reading this.
Your path is yours alone. Walk it with integrity, whether your teacher does or not.



